5 Must-Play Games Like Alan Wake 2

Alan Wake 2 made a massive impact on its 2023 release, delivering a unique horror experience that earned it multiple Game Awards and has kept players talking ever since. Remedy Entertainment proved once again they're at the top of their game when it comes to creating atmospheric, story-driven experiences.

If you've finished Alan Wake 2 and crave more games with similar vibes, several titles offer comparable gameplay elements, narrative depth, and psychological horror that made Alan Wake 2 stand out. Here are 5 games that capture the essence of Alan Wake 2:

We'll explore what these games share with Alan Wake 2, from their storytelling approaches to their gameplay mechanics. You'll also find information on their retail prices and available platforms, making it easier to decide which horror adventure to dive into next.

Also Read: 5 Must-Play Action Horror Games Like Resident Evil

1. Blair Witch

Blair Witch is a first-person psychological horror game developed by Bloober Team and released in August 2019. It's based on the Blair Witch film franchise and puts you in the Black Hills Forest of Maryland as a former police officer searching for a missing boy.

You play as Ellis Lynch, accompanied by your dog Bullet, navigating a forest that constantly shifts around you. The game's camcorder mechanic lets you replay recorded footage to manipulate the environment and solve puzzles. The horror builds through Ellis's deteriorating mental state rather than direct confrontation, keeping tension consistent throughout.

Our Opinion: Blair Witch works best when it leans into Ellis's psychology rather than the supernatural elements. Bullet plays a bigger role than expected, and the way the game uses him to reflect Ellis's mental state adds a layer that most horror games don't bother with. It's shorter than most titles on this list, but it earns its runtime.

Get Blair Witch on GameBoost → Buy Blair Witch Key

2. The Sinking City Remastered

The Sinking City Remastered launched as a surprise release in May 2025, built on Unreal Engine 5 with fully relit environments, 4K textures, improved reflections, and a new photo mode. Developer Frogwares made it a free upgrade for existing owners on all supported platforms.

You play as Charles W. Reed, a private investigator arriving in the flooded 1920s city of Oakmont, Massachusetts, to investigate visions that have been haunting him. The game blends open-world exploration with a detective system where cases can be solved in multiple ways, leading to different outcomes. The Lovecraftian setting builds dread through its oppressive atmosphere and the slow erosion of Reed's sanity.

Our Opinion: The Sinking City Remastered is the definitive way to experience Oakmont. The Unreal Engine 5 upgrade does a lot for the atmosphere, and the open investigation system gives the detective work real weight. It won't hold your hand through its mysteries, which works in its favor.

Get The Sinking City Remastered on GameBoost → Buy The Sinking City Remastered Key

Also Read: 5 Best Survival Horror Games Like Outlast

3. Control

Control was developed by Remedy Entertainment, the same studio behind Alan Wake 2, and released in August 2019. It sits within the same connected universe, sharing characters and story elements that tie the two games together directly.

You play as Jesse Faden, who arrives at the Federal Bureau of Control's headquarters and becomes its Director under unusual circumstances. The Oldest House, the FBC's brutalist headquarters, shifts and warps around you as you fight an invasive force called the Hiss using telekinetic abilities and a transforming weapon. The gameplay loop rewards exploration, and the building itself is as much a character as anyone in the story.

Our Opinion: Control is one of Remedy's best works. The combat feels genuinely creative once you stack abilities together, and the Oldest House is one of the most interesting game environments in recent memory. For Alan Wake 2 fans, the direct story connections make it essential.

Get Control on GameBoost → Buy Control (Ultimate Edition) Key

4. The Medium

The Medium was developed by Bloober Team and released in January 2021 as a next-gen exclusive before expanding to additional platforms. It marked a significant step up in production value for the studio, featuring a full orchestral score composed by Akira Yamaoka and Arkadiusz Reikowski.

You play as Marianne, a medium who can exist in both the physical world and the spirit realm simultaneously. The game's split-screen mechanic displays both worlds at the same time, requiring you to solve puzzles that span across realities. The story centers on a dark event at an abandoned resort called Niwa, which Marianne investigates after receiving a mysterious call.

Our Opinion: The Medium's dual-reality mechanic is its biggest strength and what separates it from other horror games. The split-screen segments are genuinely unsettling, and the sound design carries a lot of the tension. It's more of a walking horror experience than an action game, which suits the story it's trying to tell.

Get The Medium on GameBoost → Buy The Medium Key

Also Read: Best Psychological Horror Games Like Silent Hill

5. The Evil Within 1 & 2

The Evil Within series was directed by Shinji Mikami, the creator of the original Resident Evil, making it one of the most direct lineages to classic survival horror. Both games follow Detective Sebastian Castellanos through nightmarish environments built around trauma and psychological horror.

The first game throws Sebastian into Beacon Mental Hospital after a mass murder investigation goes wrong, dragging him into a world of grotesque creatures and shifting environments. The sequel follows him three years later as he re-enters the STEM system to find his daughter. The first game is tighter and more punishing, while the second opens up the structure without losing the horror core.

Our Opinion: The Evil Within 1 is the stronger of the two for pure survival horror tension. Resources stay scarce throughout and the enemy design is consistently unsettling. The sequel trades some of that pressure for a more accessible experience, but both are worth playing back to back.

Get The Evil Within Series on GameBoost → Buy The Evil Within Key Buy The Evil Within 2 Key

FAQs About Games Like Alan Wake 2

Q: How many hours is the Blair Witch game?

A: Blair Witch takes around 5 to 6 hours to complete. It's a shorter experience compared to most titles on this list, but the runtime suits the type of horror it delivers. There's no padding, and the pacing stays tight throughout.

Q: Is The Sinking City Remastered worth playing?

A: Yes, particularly if you enjoy detective games with a Lovecraftian atmosphere. The Unreal Engine 5 upgrade makes a noticeable difference, and the open investigation system gives the gameplay more depth than most horror titles in its range. It's the best version of the game available right now.

Q: Is Control connected to Alan Wake?

A: Yes. Both games exist within the Remedy Connected Universe, sharing characters, locations, and story threads. The AWE expansion for Control directly bridges the two games, and playing both gives you a fuller picture of the overall narrative Remedy has been building.

Q: Is The Medium a good horror game?

A: It depends on what you want from horror. The Medium focuses on atmosphere and story over action, so if you're looking for combat-heavy gameplay, it won't deliver that. The dual-reality mechanic and sound design are genuinely effective, and the pacing builds dread well without relying on jump scares.

Q: Which is scarier, The Evil Within 1 or 2?

A: The Evil Within 1 is scarier of the two. The environments are more claustrophobic, resources are tighter, and the enemy design is more unpredictable. The sequel is more open and accessible, which works against the tension the first game builds consistently.

Final Words

These five games offer experiences that capture what made Alan Wake 2 special. From Blair Witch's psychological horror to Control's direct connections in the Remedy universe, each title delivers atmospheric storytelling and supernatural elements that fans will appreciate.

What sets these games apart is their approach to horror through narrative depth rather than cheap scares. Each creates distinct worlds where reality bends, and protagonists must confront both external threats and internal demons.

Buy Game Keys