9 Best Games Like The Quarry (2026)

The Quarry is an interactive horror game about nine teenage counselors trapped at Hackett’s Quarry on the final night of summer camp. What begins as an irresponsible attempt to enjoy one more night together quickly becomes a fight for survival against violent hunters, supernatural creatures, and the group’s own questionable decisions.

Developed by Supermassive Games, The Quarry combines cinematic presentation with branching dialogue, exploration, quick-time events, and permanent character deaths. It can be played alone, passed between friends through local couch co-op, or experienced through the online Wolf Pack mode, where invited players vote on important decisions.

The recommendations below explore different parts of that formula. Some provide similar choice-driven cinematic horror, while others focus on teenage relationships, ensemble casts, supernatural mysteries, interactive movies, or decisions that determine who survives.

Here are the best games like The Quarry:

1. Until Dawn

Until Dawn is the closest possible match for The Quarry. This rebuilt version of Supermassive Games’ original horror adventure follows eight young adults who return to an isolated mountain lodge one year after two members of their group disappeared.

The story develops according to the Butterfly Effect, which allows seemingly minor actions to produce serious consequences later. Relationships, discovered clues, dialogue responses, exploration decisions, and quick-time events can all determine which characters uncover the truth and which survive until morning.

Until Dawn is more tightly structured and frightening than The Quarry, with a snowy mountain setting replacing the summer-camp atmosphere. It lacks The Quarry’s dedicated multiplayer modes, but its controllable ensemble, cinematic direction, hidden threats, and branching deaths established the formula that The Quarry later expanded.

Why It’s Similar:

• Developed from the same interactive-horror formula

• Large group of playable characters

• Permanent character deaths

• Branching decisions and relationships

• Supernatural mystery

• Multiple possible endings

My Verdict: Until Dawn remains the closest overall alternative to The Quarry. Its remote setting, vulnerable young cast, cinematic presentation, and survival-changing decisions provide almost exactly the same type of experience.

2. The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope

Buy The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope for another cinematic horror story from Supermassive Games. After a bus crashes near an abandoned New England town, five characters become trapped by an unnatural fog and haunted by visions of seventeenth-century witch trials.

Players control different members of the group while investigating buildings, uncovering secrets, and responding to supernatural encounters. Decisions affect relationships and character traits, while failed quick-time events or reckless actions can permanently remove people from the story.

Little Hope also provides two multiplayer formats. Shared Story lets two online players experience different perspectives simultaneously, while Movie Night assigns characters to as many as five local players. Its shorter campaign makes it especially suitable for a focused horror evening with friends.

Why It’s Similar:

• Developed by Supermassive Games

• Controllable ensemble cast

• Branching cinematic story

• Characters can permanently die

• Local and online multiplayer

• Supernatural mystery with multiple outcomes

My Verdict: Little Hope is the best recommendation for players who enjoyed sharing The Quarry with friends. Its bleak atmosphere and psychological themes feel different, but the decisions, deaths, and multiplayer structure are immediately familiar.

3. Killer Frequency

Killer Frequency provides a smaller and more comedic interpretation of the slasher genre. Set in 1987, it places you behind the microphone as radio host Forrest Nash, whose late-night program becomes the emergency lifeline for residents being hunted by a masked killer.

Instead of physically rescuing callers, you search the radio station for information, study maps and documents, solve puzzles, and tell frightened people how to escape. Correct advice can save a caller, while misunderstandings or poor decisions may lead directly to their death.

Killer Frequency does not have a large playable ensemble or cinematic multiplayer, but it captures the pressure of being responsible for several vulnerable characters. Its small-town setting, period soundtrack, dark humor, masked murderer, and branching survival outcomes make it a natural recommendation for The Quarry fans.

Why It’s Similar:

• Slasher-inspired horror story

• Decisions determine who survives

• Young characters in immediate danger

• Exploration and environmental puzzles

• Dark humor between frightening scenes

• Multiple outcomes based on performance

My Verdict: Killer Frequency is an excellent choice for players who enjoyed The Quarry’s slasher-movie personality. Saving someone through hurried radio instructions can be just as tense as surviving a direct monster attack.

4. Oxenfree

Get Oxenfree to follow a group of teenagers whose overnight trip to an abandoned island releases an unnatural force. You play as Alex, a rebellious teenager attempting to understand the island’s history while navigating complicated friendships and family relationships.

Its conversation system allows dialogue to continue naturally as you explore. You can answer immediately, interrupt another character, wait too long, or remain silent. These responses gradually affect how the group views Alex and influence relationships, scenes, and the story’s possible conclusions.

Although presented as a side-scrolling adventure rather than a realistic interactive movie, Oxenfree shares The Quarry’s strongest ingredients: isolated teenagers, supernatural danger, personal conflicts, hidden history, and choices made under pressure. Its compact length also encourages another playthrough to explore different relationships and discoveries.

Why It’s Similar:

• Group of teenagers in an isolated location

• Supernatural threat

• Natural branching conversations

• Decisions affect relationships

• Hidden local history

• Multiple endings and replay value

My Verdict: Oxenfree is the best alternative for players who cared as much about The Quarry’s teenagers as its monsters. The presentation is simpler, but its dialogue and relationships feel unusually natural.

5. The Expanse: A Telltale Series

The Expanse: A Telltale Series replaces summer-camp horror with a dark science-fiction story aboard a scavenging ship. You control Camina Drummer as she explores wreckage, manages a divided crew, and responds to a crisis that threatens everyone aboard the Artemis.

Conversations and leadership decisions determine which crewmates trust Drummer and how they behave during later events. Exploration also matters because supplies, discoveries, and optional objectives can create new possibilities or change whether particular characters survive.

The Expanse is not a traditional horror game, but its hostile environments, disturbing discoveries, vulnerable ensemble, and permanent consequences make it relevant to The Quarry fans. Both games repeatedly ask whether protecting one person is worth endangering another, and neither guarantees that the entire group will reach the ending alive.

Why It’s Similar:

• Dark choice-driven storytelling

• Ensemble cast under extreme pressure

• Relationships affected by dialogue

• Exploration reveals optional information

• Characters can live or die

• Multiple outcomes across the story

My Verdict: The Expanse is a strong option for players who enjoyed managing relationships and deciding who to protect. It trades supernatural horror for dangerous science fiction without removing the pressure behind each decision.

6. Song of Horror

Purchase Song of Horror to investigate the disappearance of a famous writer and the supernatural force connected to his home. The mystery is examined by several ordinary people rather than one heavily armed hero.

Each chapter provides a selection of playable characters with different backgrounds and personal connections to the mystery. If one character dies, the story continues with another investigator, who can return to the same location and recover items left behind. Losing everyone can force you to restart the chapter.

The supernatural Presence is controlled by an adaptive system that responds to how you play and creates unpredictable encounters. Song of Horror contains fewer dialogue branches than The Quarry, but the responsibility of keeping an ensemble alive—and the possibility of losing characters permanently—creates a comparable form of tension.

Why It’s Similar:

• Several playable characters

• Permanent character deaths

• Supernatural central mystery

• Exploration and clue gathering

• Actions carry lasting consequences

• Strong replay value

My Verdict: Song of Horror is considerably less forgiving than The Quarry. It is an excellent recommendation for players who want character deaths to affect both the narrative and the way each location must be explored.

7. The Wolf Among Us

The Wolf Among Us is a dark episodic murder mystery set in a hidden community populated by fairytale characters. As sheriff Bigby Wolf, you investigate a violent crime while dealing with witnesses, suspects, political tensions, and your own dangerous reputation.

Dialogue choices affect how characters respond to Bigby and whether they cooperate later. Investigations can be handled through patience, intimidation, or violence, while timed decisions prevent you from carefully considering every consequence before acting.

It is closer to supernatural noir than survival horror, but its graphic violence, unsettling mystery, cinematic direction, and branching conversations make it suitable for The Quarry fans. The main difference is perspective: instead of protecting frightened teenagers from a monster, you play the feared creature attempting to determine which apparent victim is hiding the truth.

Why It’s Similar:

• Dark episodic presentation

• Timed dialogue choices

• Supernatural characters

• Violent murder mystery

• Relationships change through your actions

• Difficult decisions with later consequences

My Verdict: The Wolf Among Us is ideal for players who enjoyed The Quarry’s conversations and hidden motives. Its mystery is more controlled, but deciding what kind of person Bigby becomes is consistently compelling.

8. Late Shift

Late Shift is a dark live-action interactive thriller starring a student who becomes involved in the theft of a valuable Chinese bowl. The entire story is presented through filmed scenes, with decisions appearing without pausing the action.

Its branching script contains numerous decision points that can move the protagonist toward different alliances, confrontations, and endings. Choices range from apparently minor responses to dangerous actions that completely redirect the night.

Late Shift does not contain monsters or a teenage ensemble, but it closely resembles The Quarry’s Movie Mode presentation. Its real actors, violent situations, uninterrupted editing, timed decisions, and seven endings make it feel like controlling a thriller rather than playing a conventional adventure game.

Why It’s Similar:

• Dark interactive-movie format

• Real actors and filmed environments

• Timed decisions

• Branching scenes

• Seven possible endings

• Designed for repeated playthroughs

My Verdict: Late Shift is the best recommendation for anyone who treated The Quarry like a playable film. It lacks supernatural horror, but its dangerous crime story and polished live-action structure provide a similar cinematic experience.

9. The Chant

The Chant is a third-person horror adventure set at a spiritual retreat on a remote island. A group ritual goes disastrously wrong and opens a doorway to the Gloom, a supernatural dimension that feeds on fear and negative energy.

You control Jess as she explores the retreat, learns what its residents are hiding, and fights creatures created by the Gloom. Survival involves managing mind, body, and spirit, gathering resources, crafting equipment, and deciding how to approach both dangerous encounters and troubled characters.

The Chant is more action-oriented and has fewer branching conversations than The Quarry, but its isolated group, suspicious hosts, supernatural history, and multiple endings create a recognizable atmosphere. It works particularly well for players who wanted more direct control during The Quarry’s dangerous encounters.

Why It’s Similar:

• Isolated retreat setting

• Group threatened by supernatural forces

• Hidden history and suspicious characters

• Exploration and collectible clues

• Decisions contribute to different endings

• Cinematic third-person presentation

My Verdict: The Chant is a worthwhile alternative when you want The Quarry’s remote setting and supernatural mystery with more combat. Its story is less flexible, but surviving the Gloom requires considerably more direct involvement.

Best Games Like The Quarry on Each Platform

Best Games Like The Quarry on PC

Every game included in this list is available on PC. Until Dawn provides the closest experience, Little Hope is best for multiplayer, and Killer Frequency offers a more comedic slasher mystery.

Players can browse PC game keys for additional horror adventures, narrative games, and interactive stories.

Best Games Like The Quarry on PlayStation

PlayStation players can access Until Dawn, Little Hope, Killer Frequency, Oxenfree, The Expanse, Song of Horror, The Wolf Among Us, Late Shift, and The Chant across PS4 and PS5.

Browse PlayStation game keys for more cinematic and choice-driven games.

Best Games Like The Quarry on Xbox

Little Hope, Killer Frequency, Oxenfree, The Expanse, Song of Horror, The Wolf Among Us, Late Shift, and The Chant are available on Xbox platforms. Little Hope is the strongest Xbox option for friends who want local or online multiplayer.

The Xbox game keys category contains more horror games and narrative adventures for Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S.

Best Games Like The Quarry on Nintendo Switch

Nintendo Switch players can choose Little Hope, Killer Frequency, Oxenfree, and Late Shift. Little Hope provides the closest cinematic-horror experience, while Oxenfree is particularly suitable for handheld play.

Players can explore Nintendo game keys for additional story-driven and horror games.

FAQs About Games Like The Quarry

Final Words

Until Dawn is the best overall alternative to The Quarry because it offers the same combination of cinematic horror, young playable characters, branching relationships, supernatural danger, and permanent deaths. Little Hope is the stronger option for multiplayer, especially when several friends want control over different characters.

Killer Frequency and Oxenfree explore the slasher and teenage-drama sides of The Quarry from different perspectives. Song of Horror provides harsher survival consequences, while The Expanse and The Wolf Among Us place greater emphasis on leadership, investigation, and dialogue.

Late Shift plays like a dark live-action movie, while The Chant adds more exploration and combat to its supernatural story. Together, these games provide familiar choice-driven tension without simply repeating every recommendation from the Until Dawn list.

GameBoost Products

View all GameBoost Game Keys

View all GameBoost Accounts

View all GameBoost Boosting Services

View all GameBoost Currencies

View all GameBoost Gift Cards

View all GameBoost Top Ups

View all GameBoost Items